Four freedoms - Printable Version

+- stella2.0 (
+-- Forum: Workshops - 2013 (/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: VATE Workshop Two 2013 (/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Thread: Four freedoms (/showthread.php?tid=15)

Four freedoms - philipthiel - 10-02-2013 10:54 PM

[Image: BVi2y14CcAA24Dx.jpg:large]

This meme sequence is my written contribution to this evening’s stella 2.0 workshop at the Victorian Association for the Teaching of English [crossposted here]. Pateman’s insights are from his 1975 book Language, Truth and Politics cited by Garth Boomer in this article.

At the workshop, I continued reflecting on these four radical suggestions (that teachers should question an unreasonable assertion; say that we don’t understand if we don’t understand; pause to think; and say that we don’t know if we don’t know), taking them in turn.

PAUSE TO THINK. What happens when a teacher pauses to think? In a culture of care and surveillance this seems like a risk. Look out the window and you’ve turned your back on the class. But anything’s better than not looking out the window.

SAY THAT WE DON’T KNOW. Euphemisms for I don’t know: I’ll get back to you; this can be a research project; let’s stay on task; does anyone else know the answer; that reminds me; which leads us back to the main idea; let’s hear from some other people; it’s time to work independently; quiet.

SAY THAT WE DON’T UNDERSTAND. My mother taught me two cliches: “you’re not late until you arrive late” and “people just want to hear I understand.” Teachers modelling confusion seems rare enough to be a taboo, but I do some of my best thinking when my friends make a perplexed expression. The blanker they look, the better I talk.

QUESTION AN UNREASONABLE ASSERTION. Assertions worth questioning: that English should be interesting; that English is dull; that Shakespeare is great; that Shakespeare is unreadable; that one person should speak at a time; that we should face the front; that we should pull up our socks; that we should wear socks; that a rule must have consequences; that consequences can be predicted; that the lesson is over.